mastouille.fr est l'un des nombreux serveurs Mastodon indépendants que vous pouvez utiliser pour participer au fédiverse.
Mastouille est une instance Mastodon durable, ouverte, et hébergée en France.

Administré par :

Statistiques du serveur :

655
comptes actifs

#aicoding

0 message0 participant0 message aujourd’hui
A répondu dans un fil de discussion

"... AI code assistants invent package names. In a recent study, researchers found that about 5.2 percent of package suggestions from commercial models didn't exist, compared to 21.7 percent from open source or openly available models.

Running that code should result in an error when importing a non-existent package. But miscreants have realized that they can hijack the hallucination for their own benefit."

#ThomasClaburn, 2025

theregister.com/2025/04/12/ai_

(1/2)

#AI #MOLE #AICoding

@worik

The Register · LLMs can't stop making up software dependencies and sabotaging everythingPar Thomas Claburn
A répondu dans un fil de discussion

@elementary tl;dr I support your objectives, and kudos on the goal, but I think you should monitor this new policy for unexpected negative outcomes. I take about 9k characters to explain why, but I’m not criticizing your intent.

While I am much more pragmatic about my stance on #aicoding this was previously a long-running issue of contention on the #StackExchange network that was never really effectively resolved outside of a few clearly egregious cases.

The triple-net is that when it comes to certain parts of software—think of the SCO copyright trials over header files from a few decades back—in many cases, obvious code will be, well…obvious. That “the simplest thing that could possibly work” was produced by an AI instead of a person is difficult to prove using existing tools, and false accusations of plagiarism have been a huge problem that has caused a number of people real #reputationalharm over the last couple of years.

That said, I don’t disagree with the stance that #vibecoding is not worth the pixels that it takes up on a screen. From a more pragmatic standpoint, though, it may be more useful to address the underlying principle that #plagiarism is unacceptable from a community standards or copyright perspective rather than making it a tool-specific policy issue.

I’m a firm believer that people have the right to run their community projects in whatever way best serves their community members. I’m only pointing out the pragmatic issues of setting forth a policy where the likelihood of false positives is quite high, and the level of pragmatic enforceability may be quite low. That is something that could lead to reputational harm to people and the project, or to community in-fighting down the road, when the real policy you’re promoting (as I understand it) is just a fundamental expectation of “original human contributions” to the project.

Because I work in #riskmanagement and #cybersecurity I see this a lot. This is an issue that comes up more often than you might think. Again, I fully support your objectives, but just wanted to offer an alternative viewpoint that your project might want to revisit down the road if the current policy doesn’t achieve the results that you’re hoping for.

In the meantime, I certainly wish you every possible success! You’re taking a #thoughtleadership stance on an important #AIgovernance policy issue that is important to society and to #FOSS right now. I think that’s terrific!

I assess the state of dev tools in the AI-assisted coding era: from AI plugins for common IDEs, to agentic IDEs, to cloud native AI tooling. As you might imagine, it's an incredibly crowded field of AI coding vendors. I'm not a professional dev, but for my various web projects I use a combo of VS Code + Copilot (I do want to try Google's one too), ChatGPT (I pay for the Pro version) and playing around with new apps like Bolt and Warp. How about you? thenewstack.io/ai-powered-codi #AIcoding

The New Stack · AI Coding Trends: Developer Tools To Watch in 2025We assess the state of dev tools in the AI-assisted coding era: from AI plugins for common IDEs, to agentic IDEs, to cloud native AI tooling.

Google has just launched Gemini Code Assist for individuals, a free AI-coding assistant offering *90 times* more code completions than GitHub Copilot. Reminiscent of when Google launched Gmail in 2004 offering one gigabyte of storage space — more than 100 times what Yahoo and Microsoft had at the time. thenewstack.io/google-ai-codin #AIcoding #aidevelopment tip @Techmeme

The New Stack · Google AI Coding Tool Now Free, With 90x Copilot’s OutputGoogle launches Gemini Code Assist for individuals, a free AI-coding assistant offering 90 times more code completions than GitHub Copilot.

🧠 Devs gaining little (if anything) from AI coding assistants
— CIO

「 In addition to measuring productivity, the Uplevel study looked at factors in developer burnout, and it found that GitHub Copilot hasn’t helped there, either. The amount of working time spent outside of standard hours decreased for both the control group and the test group using the coding tool, but it decreased more when the developers weren’t using Copilot 」

cio.com/article/3540579/devs-g

CIODevs gaining little (if anything) from AI coding assistantsCode analysis firm sees no major benefits from AI dev tool when measuring key programming metrics, though others report incremental gains from coding copilots with emphasis on code review.

> .> Joseph Saveri and Matthew Butterick, the attorneys representing the authors, in January also sued Stability AI on behalf of visual artists who accused the "parasite" app of glomming off their work. Last year the duo filed a lawsuit against GitHub, alleging its AI-assisted coding tool built on stolen coders' work.
- cbsnews.com/news/sarah-silverm

#MatthewButterick of #BeautifulRacket in court against #StabilityAI and #GitHub for #AIcoding along with other #AISalami apps like #ChatGPT